Trial Court Decision Page 1

Trial Court Decision Page 2

Trial Court Decision Page 3

Trial Court Decision Page 4

Trial Court Decision Page 5

Trial Court Decision Page 6

Trial Court Decision Page 7

Trial Court Decision Page 8

Trial Court Decision Page 9

Trial Court Decision Page 10

Trial Court Decision Page 11

Trial Court Decision Page 12

Trial Court Decision Page 13

Trial Court Decision Page 14

Trial Court Decision Page 15

Trial Court Decision Page 16

Trial Court Decision Page 17

Trial Court Decision Page 18

Trial Court Decision Page 19

Trial Court Decision Page 20

Trial Court Decision Page 21

Trial Court Decision Page 22

Trial Court Decision Page 23

Trial Court Decision Page 24

Trial Court Decision Page 25

Trial Court Decision Page 26

Trial Court Decision Page 27

Trial Court Decision Page 28

Trial Court Decision Page 29

Trial Court Decision Page 30

Trial Court Decision Page 31

Trial Court Decision Page 32

Trial Court Decision Page 33

Trial Court Decision Page 34

Trial Court Decision Page 35

Trial Court Decision Page 36